As with all work, there's a right tool for every job. In manufacturing, successful machining depends on sharp, well-maintained cutting tools that not only ensure precision, but also speed. Successful sharpening of cutting tools depends upon the use of the correct grinding wheel, tool setup and method of grinding for each type of tool. This article provides some basic but valuable information on cutting tool sharpening. The process is designed to keep manufacturing flow as efficient as possible, ensuring better competitiveness nationally and even globally.

The most common method to sharpen a worn out tool is through “grinding.” Both conventional (aluminum oxide and silicon carbide) and super abrasive (cubic boron nitride, CBN) wheels are used for this purpose. However, conventional wheels dull faster, become glazed and burnished, thus reducing grinding productivity and causing thermal/metallurgical damage to the tool being ground. When looking at choosing a grinding wheel, and looking at costs of improvement vs. the effect to the bottom line, here are some major factors that make CBN wheels a better choice than conventional wheels for sharpening cutting tools:

CBN grains have 55 times more thermal conductivity, four times more abrasive resistance and twice the hardness of aluminum oxide abrasives. This combination makes CBN wheels especially well-suited for the grinding of high-speed and super-alloy steel tools, providing:

  • long wheel life at high material removal rates;
  • little or no thermal damage to the cutting edge because of the cool cutting action;
  • consistent sharp, burr-free cutting edges with no loss of hardness;
  • easy and more effective control over tool sizes, shapes and finishes; and,
  • increased tool grinding productivity because of less downtime due to wheel breakdown and conditioning, and less time required for gauging, spark-out and wheel changes.

CBN grains do not chemically react with steels and retain their strength above 10,000 degrees Celsius. Grinding with CBN wheels also improves the fatigue strength and extends the useful life of the cutting tool.

However, before replacing an aluminum oxide wheel with a CBN grinding wheel, it is important to make sure that the grinding system can take advantage of the productivity potential that a CBN wheel offers. The major factors to be considered are:

  • the grinding machine (which must have tight spindle bearings and close-fitting slides to eliminate vibration and chatter, constant spindle speed to boost efficiency and reliable feed rates to preserve wheel life);
  • horsepower requirements (material ground with CBN wheels are usually hard and require more horsepower to remove a given amount of material from the workpiece); and,
  • the proper use of coolant.

Wheel Selection

When selecting a CBN wheel for tool and cutter grinding operations, the following points must be considered:

Bond type: The bond is a primary consideration in selecting the proper CBN grinding wheel. Resin-bond wheels are used for most tool and cutter grinder operations. Electroplated wheels are used when form grinding.

Grit size: When replacing an aluminum oxide wheel with a CBN wheel, it is wise to follow the recommendations listed in the following table regarding grit sizes.

COMPARATIVE GRIT SIZES
Aluminum Oxide wheels CBN Wheels
46-60 80-140
80-120 170-325
150-220 325-400

Concentration: Wheels with concentration levels of 75 to 100 are recommended because they provide good material-removal rates and long wheel life, and are usually the most cost-effective.

The factors such as the grinding method, grinding mode, and the speed and feed rates used also affect the efficiency of a tool and cutter grinding operation. For example, the grinding method can be either wet or dry, and both can be used with success. Dry grinding with a resin-bond CBN wheel has proved to be effective. Low feed rates are recommended to prevent workpiece burning during dry grinding. Wet grinding with either straight oil or a heavy-duty, water soluble oil is very effective. It is important that the cutting fluid be applied directly to the work-wheel interface for the maximum cooling and lubrication.

As far as grinding mode is concerned, if the grinder has sufficient power and rigidity, creep-feed, single-pass grinding is recommended. Generally, this mode of grinding produces the highest productivity, longest wheel life and best workpiece finish. Conventional multi-pass grinding is also very effective for most tool and cutter grinding operations. The recommended wheel speeds during dry grinding is in the range of 3,000 to 4,500 surface feet per minute (15 to 23 meters per second). The higher wheel speeds may cause burning of the tool edges. In wet grinding, wheel speeds in the range of 5,000 to 6,500 SFPM (25 to 33 m/s) provide excellent results. In general, the higher speeds improve both wheel life and metal-removal rates.

The traverse feed rate should be kept constant because of the cool, free-cutting characteristics of CBN grinding wheels. Whenever possible, use the creep-feed, single-pass grinding mode. Use lower feed rates when grinding dry. Roughing cuts should be about 0.002 inches (0.05 millimeters) deep, while finish cuts are usually 0.005 to 0.001 inches (0.01 to 0.02 millimeters) deep. Spark-out passes are not necessary when using CBN wheels because if the grinder is in good condition, whatever is set for the depth of cut is what is removed from the tool being ground.

To make the grinding operation successful, CBN wheels should be mounted on a high-quality adapter and should be kept together as a unit for the life of the wheel. A dial indicator should be used to true the wheel to within 0.001 inches (0.02 millimeters) or less run-out on the wheel face. Also, an appropriate truing device should be used for a given type of CBN wheel, and the wheel should be trued and properly dressed on the machine on which it will be used.

In recent years, new developments have been made in tool grinding machines that combine automation with flexibility, and promise increased precision and productivity. The use of CBN grinding wheels for the grinding of end mills, milling cutters, hobs,and a variety of hardened cutting tools can reduce the cost of grinding at the same time producing better quality cutting edges. As CBN wheels last much longer than do conventional grinding wheels and require little or no conditioning, there is less downtime for wheel maintenance The savings in grinding costs with CBN wheels may range from 20 to 50 percent, or even higher depending on applications.

About the author:

Dr. Anil Srivastava is the manager of manufacturing technology at TechSolve in Cincinnati. He has more than 30 years of research, teaching and experience in manufacturing, specifically in the areas of machining and grinding. Dr. Srivastava received his Ph.D. degree in Mechanical Engineering from the Indian Institute of Technology in Kanpur, India. He has managed numerous industrial projects related to optimization of the machining process, cost-effective machining of materials, evaluation of cutting tools/coatings performance and metal working fluids. He is currently managing a three-year, $6 million project awarded by NIST-ATP to develop intelligent optimization and control of grinding processes.

About TechSolve:

Founded in 1982, the people, products and services of TechSolve are at work to increase efficiency and product flow for hundreds of manufacturers and technology providers across a broad spectrum of industries. The organization provides assessments and consulting, testing and implementation, and training to successful manufacturers looking to optimize and continuously improve their business, making it more profitable and more competitive. Headquartered in Cincinnati, TechSolve employs 60 and has more than 200 companies in its membership organization. For more information, visit www.techsolve.org or call 513-948-2000.