- Buyer's Guide
It might seem trivial, but the best way to improve reliability is to choose equipment that doesn’t break down! At the very least, choose designs that when they do fail, they are easy, inexpensive and quick to fix. With the right choices in the beginning, maintenance departments can guarantee maintainability. The field of guaranteed maintainability was coined by Atlanta-based consultant Ed Feldman.
There are three enemies to the ability of the maintenance department to guarantee the maintainability of a plant or facility. The first enemy to guaranteed maintainability is buying low bid without regard for experience, specification, use or service. Low-bid specifications are seldom designed to exclude major manufacturers’ models just because they didn’t perform in the past. The second enemy is mental laziness where the maintenance people never thought through performance of the assets and cannot identify the best brands of anything based on real data (but they do have opinions about everything). The third enemy is time. Where maintenance has input into the process of design, it is usually a one- or two-day window and it might be too late in the design cycle for changes anyway.
When designing new plants, machines or processes, for example, there are thousands of decisions that will have an impact on maintainability.
Nine areas to consider in the design and specification of new assets are as follows:
Access: Some factories are virtual rats’ nests of wires, pipes, ducts, chutes and machines. Access impacts maintainability. Items that cannot be easily accessed will not be addressed with preventive maintenance. In the office of a plant in western Pennsylvania, the HVAC subsystems including the filter locations were located in 11-foot ceilings above the hallways. The ceilings were drop-in tiles with no catwalks, and were filled with wires, pipes, supports and insulation. Changing filters and lubricating the units was a dangerous, time-consuming and dirty ordeal. One of the rules of guaranteed maintainability is to make required maintenance easy to perform.
Commissioning and turnover: How is the asset turned over to the users and the maintenance department? When the asset is contracted for (to build a new building or machine), the purchase documents should spell out the conditions for turnover.
In a building, the turnover happens when the architect’s punch list is completed. After that, a warrantee period starts to allow latent defects to come to the surface. In a machine, turnover might be completed when the production level reaches an agreed-upon benchmark.
Consider the following as part of your turnover process:
• Documentation in an agreed-upon form in the hands of the maintenance department.
• A videotaped walk-through with maintenance personnel showing all adjustments, shutoffs, operation, etc
• Training sessions on- or off-site in repair, failure modes and optimization
• Coupons for several future training sessions (we can dream, can’t we?).
Components and parts: Are the parts needed to service the new asset the same as the parts already in stock? Secondly, are the parts available from vendors already known to be reliable to your company? When I computerized the delivery of products in an oil terminal, I was told by the manager that I could use any motor controllers I wanted to as long as they were available from Square D. He had existing stock of Square D and a great relationship with the local dealer.
In a subsidized housing development, the contractor submitted (and got approved) specifications for an imported furnace as an equal to the one called for on the drawings. At the time, no spare furnaces or spare parts were bought. Two years after the property was commissioned, a unit broke down. The wait for parts was nine months. The management company was forced to refit the apartments with new domestic units as the imported ones broke down.
Design: A manufacturer was having problems with bearing failure. He completed failure analysis and found some of the bearings were not getting greased and others were getting over greased. Only one out of three were getting proper greasing. He installed an automated greasing system and eliminated bearing failure. He has incorporated automated lubrication into his specifications for all new equipment.
Design is the most important single element of reliability. It is shocking how many competent manufacturers don’t have reliable data about failure on the components for which they rely. Your CMMS is a great source of data when the categories are set up correctly and the work orders are filled out and entered accurately.
Documentation: One of the aspects of guaranteed maintainability is the ability to get vital information when you need it. Equipment vendors are notoriously variable in the quality, organization and usability of their support documentation. See if the vendor maintains a site on the Internet where you can access technical data, including parts lists and wiring diagrams, and get technical help. Web sites for maintenance and repair are more and more common and a real bonus for you.
Lucent Technologies (formally AT&T) now specifies how the manual and support documentation should be constructed in its purchase orders for new equipment. This is part of their ISO 900X process. Even if you don’t go this far, it is important to make sure that the documentation will serve your needs and you will get adequate copies.
They specify the chapters and contents of the manual:
• What is the asset?
• What does it do, including detailed functional specifications?
• Complete description of how the asset works.
• What are the components?
• What should be done if it is not working up to specification (broken up by component)?
• What are the safety and environmental considerations (how can it hurt me or the environment)?
Installation: When a contractor installs a piece of new equipment, they might not look at the long-term need for maintenance (this is one area where having a close liaison with the contractor insures that good maintenance techniques and standards are followed). Simple things like well-positioned shutoff valves, convenient disconnects, and orientation of the unit to allow easy servicing and positioning the unit to avoid damage from lift trucks or cranes make a major difference in your ability to maintain the asset.
Skills needed to repair: Whenever you change models or manufacturers, there will be a learning curve. It is important to evaluate the cost of the learning curve and see if the change in make or model is a justifiable improvement in production levels, reliability, efficiency or use. In the absence of a good reason to change, why change? Does the vendor include training and retraining as part of the new equipment package?
Surfaces/finishes: This is very important for buildings and parts of machines that come in contact with product. Some surfaces are better (last longer, are easier to clean, etc.) than others. Rutgers University in New Brunswick, N.J., specified a solid-surface material such as Corian in the dorm bathrooms instead of tile. Solid-surface material is more expensive but almost undamageable (and it can be repaired if it is damaged).
Tools: Do you have the specialized tools needed to service this new type of asset? How much money will need to be spent for new tools? If a new class of asset is chosen, be sure the new tools are included in the budget and acquired.
Guaranteed maintainability has other aspects that are important. These include:
• Maintenance needs to know how to operate the equipment as well as operators. At GE Engineered plastics, the maintenance department personnel were certified operators at the plant.
• Unfortunately, many maintenance professionals do not have good networks of maintenance people in other companies. Product intelligence, repair experience and re-engineering tips can all come from a well-cultivated network.
• If your business depends on a manufacturer’s equipment, be sure to visit the factory where the asset was built. Meet the behind-the-scenes engineers and shop people. These people can become a great resource. Be sure to let them know how important their equipment is to your operation. Bring pictures of their “babies” that you put to work.
About the author:
Joel Levitt is a leading trainer of maintenance professionals. He has trained more than 10,000 maintenance leaders from 3,000 organizations in 20 countries in over 500 sessions. Since 1980, he has been the president of Springfield Resources, a management consulting firm that services all sized clients on a wide range of maintenance issues. He has almost 25 years experience in many facets of maintenance, including as a process control designer, source equipment inspector, electrician, field service technician, merchant marine worker, manufacturing manager and property manager. Prior to that Levitt worked for a CMMS vendor and in manufacturing management. To learn more, visit www.maintrainer.com or call 800-242-5656.